What's More Important Than An Interview?
The other day I applied for an HR Generalist job with a very well known online portal. When I say very well known, I mean to the tune of having 17 million + unique visitors per month this year.
So, here's how things went:
An assistant to a non-HR big-wig called me for a phone screen. It was the best kind of phone screen: short but thorough. The assistant said she would "walk" my resume and her notes over to the hiring manager so I could be contacted by her to set up an interview.
Great! Sounds good.
Later that day, someone from the Recruiting Department (halfway across the country) called me to schedule an interview with the hiring manager. Ok, whatevs. Sounds fine to me.
The interview was scheduled for the next day. Good! I hate waiting a week or week and a half for an interview. Let's get it over with as soon as we can.
I arrive for the interview. The assistant that originally phone screened me came out to say hello and offer me water, coffee, tea, Jack Daniels. You know, the usual.
Then the hiring manager came out to greet me. We went to her office where the first thing she told me was, unfortunately, someone had rescheduled a meeting in the middle of our interview time slot, so our time would be cut short.
Wait. What?
She apologized, but didn't seem mortified. I attempted to be gracious about it. Inside my head I was thinking,
What is more important than an interview? Have I ever allowed anything short of a medical emergency infringe upon an interview with a candidate? No...I don't think I have. Well, maybe there was some sort of emergency and they are handling damage control at the meeting...Thus, the interview began.
We chit-chatted about the company. I told her I had read x, y and z about the organization and blah blah blah. We walked through my resume, which went well besides the fact I was 98% sure she hadn't even read it before I walked through the door.
She then asked me what I felt my three best skills were. I listed them and gave one to two sentences of "supporting evidence" for each. Two of the skills I listed were essential functions of the position I was applying for, and the third was "gravy".
Well, not literally gravy. But you know what I mean.
She then went on to tell me x, y and z about the organization. I thought this was a little weird as I had just told her I had read about those exact things, and she didn't give me any new information or insight in her description. However, she did go on for a solid five minutes, at least.
Then, this is the best part, she said, "Well, do you have any questions?"
I think I jumped a little in my seat. She had asked me one question (well, besides the "let's walk through your resume, ok?" part). We were just getting started, yo!
So I said, "Yes. What is HR's main role in the organization?"
She then went on another five minute rant. I learned how many people work in HR and where they are located; who she reports to; who reports to her and that their turnover is usually comprised of employees that have been with the company one year or less.
What I did not learn was what HR's main role in the organization was.
Then, she squinted at her computer screen and said, "Oh, I have to go to that meeting now". She walked me to the lobby and shook my hand.
------
A few days later, I received a "thanks but no thanks" email from the Recruiter that set up the interview.
Just for kicks, I called the hiring manager and left her a message requesting feedback on my resume and interview so I can, you know, better tailor my search.
I have $5 that says I never hear from her again.
Cross posted at BlogHer


18 comments:
O.
M.
G.
What a crock of shit. These HR people ought to be ashamed of themselves, yo.
i'd bet the boss' nephew got the job. and she knew that before you got there but after they scheduled the interview. uh huh. something like that.
crock of shit.
that's the perfect way to describe it.
at least you know you don't want to work there!
all the best!
deb
They owed you the option of rescheduling. That was incredibly poor form. Makes me wonder what kind of leadership the place has.
Yeah, I agree with Deb. Reeks of position getting filled (or becoming likely to be filled) after the interview was scheduled and them not bothering to just tell you that, and her just going through the motions (although not even really bothering with most of the motions). It's BS.
I didn't even think of that (that the job may have been filled before I interviewed). Huh. Could be.
I was technically over qualified, but figured they were going with "preferred" vs "required" qualifications.
Whether the position was already filled or not, they wasted your time but at least you know that you don't want to work there. They simply don't deserve you!
But at least you got some inspiration for a post ;-)
Actually, making really good gravy is a skill that I might hire you for. It's not as easy as it looks ;)
Wow, that interview was the in-person equivalent of a generic form letter.
I'm almost impressed by the hiring manager's lack of interactivity.
I will see your five bucks about not getting a response back. That is just straight-up messed up.
Sounds like you interviewed with someone who was very, very new to the hiring process.
Happy - I see everything as blog post fodder these days. Isn't that sad?
Franny - Dude, I have never made gravy in my life. I leave that to my mom.
Perrik - That's a good analogy!
Kelly - Now we just need someone to bet against us!
Anon - I don't think she's new. I think she just didn't care. About a lot of things...
That B L O W S ! Totally unprofessional and irritating. I'm sorry, HRW, but they totally don't deserve you !
Kimberley - I sure hope someone in the PDX area deserves me, pickings are getting slim! :)
I was thinking the same thing as Deb - minus the nepotism part. Position was likely filled before you walked through the door.
Corey - Between the phone screen and the in person there was like 32 hours. They are fast!
Very rude - so you wouldn't want to work with/for someone like that would you?
Excellent question about the role of HR in that organisation. Clearly she did not know the answer (sadly, not unusual) which is why HR often comes in for so much flak.
That in-person interview was a waste of makeup, if you ask me. Everything was great until that point -- and who would want to work for that hiring manager? 10 to 1 they had an internal candidate that the hiring manager wanted but had to go through the motions of "interviewing" other people. At least you got a blog post out of it!
Good thing I don't wear make up! ;) Actually, I did just buy some Bare Escentuals mineral make up but haven't tried it yet.
Oh well, at least it was interview experience (which is good for everyone!).
Post a Comment